Hot News!

Smitherman talks about early voting on MSNBC



Visit us at Twitter!

Wednesday, June 02, 2010

Cincinnati 9/12 Project Stands Up for Waste, Fraud, and Abuse, while plagiarizing left wing blogger!

Posted by Cincinnati Beacon Staff

Photo courtesy of here.

Guest article by Coleman Kane

So I decided to partake in my weekly dose of Wingnutistan flagellation from “the right” and came across this Gem on the website of the Cincinnati 9/12 Project during my dumpster dive.  It delves into a criticism of tightening of government screws in the tax laws in an attempt to eliminate what many consider to be one of the bigger fraud/abuse/waste contributors in our antiquated system: Non-qualifying, tax-exempted “expenses”—for instance, when an SBE owner buys a new laptop for his college-bound daughter and writes it off as a “business expense.”

You’d think that, in the climate of horrible private sector disasters like the BP oil spill, maybe the Cincinnati 9/12 Project, which laments upon the failure of government to eliminate its own waste, would welcome an attempt by legislators to scrutinize this practice more, and hopefully get more non-paying entities to pay taxes that are due.

That’s not the worst offense though… The Cincinnati 9/12 Project bills this as an article written by “a CPA, whose profession is to keep up on all tax laws and keep his clients (small businesses) in compliance” supposedly named “Wayne”. About half-way through the article I got the tingly feeling of Deja Vu. I had already read this.

In fact, I had. The “article” was almost a verbatim regurgitation of another one, published roughly a month earlier on CNN’s website, and written by one Neil deMause. Here is the CNN link, and here’s one from Neil’s own website.

Notice how, save for some superficial changes to wording, they are almost identical? Even the idea flow and paragraph breaks match up! In fact, the major changes to the article were solely to remove the citations from other sources, which include opposition to and support of the new law changes, as well as comments by a legislative aide involved in the legislation.

What’s more—Neil’s a writer for CNN and many other publications, including NYC publications such as The Village Voice and City Limits. So the Cincinnati 9/12 Project plagiarizes an east-coast Ivy League writer to make their point (badly).

I wish that I could say that this is an isolated occurrence. I’d be mistaken if I did make such a claim. Unfortunately, as was shown by Andrew Breitbart’s protege James O’Keefe, as well as the recent textbook changes in Texas, and any patron of the Glenn Beck Show on Fox can attest: the movement that includes Beck, the Cincinnati Tea Party, COAST, and this Cincinnati 9/12 Project is being marked more and more by revisionist history and selectively edited reporting that conspire to create the story that the writer wants, rather than report the story that the writer sees.

Coleman Kane
Secretary, Hamilton County Young Democrats

Share This Article! | Listen to this article |

Help The Cincinnati Beacon Grow! Participate in Social Networking!


Auto-login on future visits

Show my name in the online users list

Forgot your password?


Tell us what you think!

Anonymous comments are allowed, but you can create an account above to stamp your name and to avoid typing the anti-spam code.

If you are not familiar with our rules for leaving comments, click here! The Cincinnati Beacon is not responsible for the contents of any comments. Comments do not represent the views of the moderators of The Cincinnati Beacon.

  1. .Cincy..Capell. says:

    Good catch Coleman!Bet that you needed a shower after visiting that Glenn Beckster freak website.

  2. .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) says:

    To be fair, when I notified the 9/12ers about the plagiarism, they took it down immediately and apologized profusely. So I think it’s entirely possible that they were simply snookered by this “Wayne” guy who passed off a doctored version of my article as his own.

    Of course, I still don’t get how my article is supposed to be evidence that the health care bill is socialism, but that’s a separate argument.

  3. Coleman Kane says:

    Reposts of outside articles are common form at the Cincinnati Tea Party’s website. Usually they identify the article as a re-post, and give credit to the real original author. I called them out on one which was a repost of a hoax article awhile back (after snickering a bit), and the article mysteriously vanished from their site. However, that one wasn’t so blatantly ripped either.

    Glad to hear that you actually received an apology. Reading your article earlier last month, some of it’s catchy wording was still fresh in my mind. At this point (as can be gleaned from the Sestak “deal-or-no-deal” hubub) they’ll latch onto anything to argue that it makes Obama a socialist. I’m waiting to see how letting BP fail four times in a row to come up with a private-market solution to stop a leaking oil well is going to be considered socialist, but it sounds like Palin’s working on the argument for that one (something about how “drill here drill now” in no way meant drill in the sea?).

    Perhaps this episode will encourage them to wield a bit more scrutiny over the information they reprint. Unfortunately they still are all convinced that James O’Keefe’s works are the gospel.

  4. .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address) says:
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.

Creative Commons LicenseThis work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 License.